Robinho
from Real Madrid
£32.5m
British record fee at the time

Nine seasons. Disguised sponsorship funding. Hidden costs. Every serious financial charge proved by the Commission, with sanctions still to come.
Stay with the story
Get the next chapter.
The figures / side by side
The two sides of the accounting picture: revenue recorded as sponsorship, and costs the Commission says were left out. Not a season-by-season ledger: the published appendices are redacted.
BBC Sport's itemisation of the £949.94m recorded as sponsorship across nine seasons, 2009/10 to 2017/18.

A separate set of sums, from the Commission's redacted decision rather than the BBC itemisation. They are not part of the sponsorship totals above.
Source: the Commission's redacted decision
Bars compare omitted expenses only, scaled to £49.414m. The separate £24.5m Fordham income reclassification is not included in these bars. Figures are from paragraph 101(b–e) of the redacted core decision; they are not a breakdown of individual sponsors’ contracts.
The squad / 2008–2018
The headline signings of the nine-season period, with the fees widely reported at the time. These fees are contemporary press figures, not Commission findings. The published decision does not link the funding findings to any individual transfer.
from Real Madrid
£32.5m
British record fee at the time
from Manchester United
£25m
fee disputed; widely reported figure
from Arsenal
£25m
from Barcelona
£24m
from Valencia
£24m
from Inter Milan
£24m
from Atlético Madrid
£38m
club record at the time
from Shakhtar Donetsk
£34m
from VfL Wolfsburg
£55m
club record at the time
from Liverpool
£49m
from Everton
£47.5m
from Tottenham Hotspur
£50m
from Benfica
£35m
from Athletic Club
£57m
club record at the time
Fees are the figures reported by BBC Sport and other outlets at the time of each signing; several were officially undisclosed. Honours count major trophies won with City while in the squad (Premier League, Champions League, FA Cup, League Cup, Community Shield, Club World Cup, UEFA Super Cup), per club records; individual wages are not published, so only the club's annual wage bill from its accounts is shown. Photos: Wikimedia Commons and Shutterstock. Spending alongside a finding does not establish which transfers, if any, the owner funding paid for.

The honours of an era.
The honours / 2009/10–2017/18
Every major trophy lifted during the nine seasons covered by the findings. The Commission's decision covers finances, not results: no title has been stripped, and what happens to these honours, if anything, is for the sanctions stage.
×3
Premier League
2011/12 · 2013/14 · 2017/18
Including the 100-point season, 2017/18
×1
FA Cup
2010/11
The first trophy of the era, ending a 35-year wait
×3
League Cup
2013/14 · 2015/16 · 2017/18
Three wins in five seasons
×1
Community Shield
2012
Season curtain-raiser after the first title
8 major trophies across the nine seasons
Honours per club records. Three league titles, one FA Cup, three League Cups and one Community Shield were won while the funding the Commission ruled on was flowing into the club.

The story, season by season.
The chronology / four chapters
Start with the ownership change, then follow the money through nine seasons to the decision. Every finding has a source; no figures shown here are fines or repayment orders.
Chapter 01 / 2008–2010
How it started
The club’s ownership changed, financial pressure grew and the Commission says owner funding began to be recorded as sponsorship.
September 2008 / 2008
Abu Dhabi United Group (ADUG) acquires City. By late 2009, the Commission says the club anticipated substantial losses and needed owner equity to fund its ambitions.
2009/10 season / 2009
City feared its loss might exceed the then-record £140m single-season Premier League loss. The Commission says the club wanted to avoid that outcome while meeting future financial fair-play rules.
Early 2010 / 2010
The Commission found that certain sponsorship contracts stated a fee that the commercial partner was not actually liable to pay in full. The sponsor paid a smaller base sum; ADUG paid the balance, called the ‘tagged sum’. City recorded the whole amount as commercial income rather than identifying the owner funding as equity.
How the recorded sponsorship fee worked
Nine-season aggregate from BBC Sport: £119.25m paid by sponsors, £830.69m by owners, of £949.94m recorded. Rounded chart shares; not a contract-by-contract split. BBC Sport
Chapter 02 / 2009–2018
What the accounts showed
Nine seasons of reported figures, the image-rights arrangement and other costs the Commission says were left out.
Nine seasons · 2009/10–2017/18 / 2009–18
The Commission found owner-funded sums were recorded as sponsorship income. BBC Sport has broken the published findings down season by season and placed them beside reported transfer spending and league results. The columns show what happened at the same time; they do not establish which purchases the funding paid for.
League 5th
Transfers · £126m
Arrivals: Tevez, Adebayor, Lescott, Santa Cruz, Kolo Touré, Barry
League 3rd · FA Cup
Transfers · £157m
Arrivals: Džeko, Yaya Touré, Balotelli, Silva, Kolarov, Milner
League 1st
Transfers · £78m
Arrivals: Agüero, Nasri, Savić, Clichy
League 2nd
Transfers · £53m
Arrivals: García, Nastasić, Rodwell, Sinclair, Maicon
League 1st · EFL Cup
Transfers · £99m
Arrivals: Fernandinho, Jovetić, Negredo, Navas
League 2nd
Transfers · £88m
Arrivals: Mangala, Bony, Fernando, Caballero
League 4th · EFL Cup
Transfers · £179m
Arrivals: De Bruyne, Sterling, Otamendi, Delph
League 3rd
Transfers · £185m
Arrivals: Stones, Sané, Jesus, Gündoğan, Bravo, Nolito
League 1st · EFL Cup
Transfers · £272m
Arrivals: Laporte, Mendy, Walker, Bernardo, Ederson, Danilo
Recorded total
£949.94m
Sponsors paid
£119.25m
Owner-funded balance
£830.69m
BBC Sport reports about £1.2bn in transfer spending and seven major domestic trophies over the period.
Seasonal sponsorship, transfer and results figures: BBC Sport . Financial findings: Commission decision, paragraph 101(a) . Transfer spending is separate from the accounting sums; this comparison does not trace individual transfers to particular funding or prove a counterfactual result. The published decision does not identify every redacted contract.
Third quarter of 2012 / 2012
City began a programme to increase revenue and reduce operating losses. The Commission accepted that many strands were legitimate; it singled out the Fordham image-rights arrangement as not legitimate.
Fordham arrangement / From 2012
The Commission found that a fee for players’ image rights was in substance owner funding, not operating income. It also found that image-rights payments made by ADUG should have appeared as City’s operating expenses.
Fordham arrangement · continued / From 2012
The same arrangement left £49.414m of operating expenses out of the club’s accounts, according to the Commission. This is a distinct accounting effect from the £24.5m income finding.
Remuneration arrangements / 2009–18
The redacted decision identifies three ADUG-funded remuneration arrangements whose true liabilities were not reflected in City's accounts. Names and some contract details are redacted in the public version, so these amounts should not be assigned to named individuals from the decision alone.
£8.866m
arrangement A
£7.4m
arrangement B
£0.5m
arrangement C
May 2013–2014 / 2013
With less than a week left in the 2012/13 financial year, the Commission says City faced an unexpected shortfall against UEFA's break-even rules. Within days, amended sponsorship agreements recorded extra Abu Dhabi income even though the sponsors had not been approached. UEFA later questioned certain sponsorship agreements and City's compliance. No finding was made in that investigation; the parties entered a settlement in May 2014. The Commission later found the submitted figures included disguised sponsorship income.
From 2015/16 / 2015
Premier League Profitability and Sustainability Rules used a £105m loss threshold over a rolling three-year period. The Commission found City in significant breach of Premier League and UEFA spending limits.
Chapter 03 / 2018–2024
How it was investigated
The leaked material, the separate UEFA case, the Premier League charges and the private hearing.
November–December 2018 / 2018
Der Spiegel published leaked material in November, supplied by Rui Pinto, the Portuguese whistleblower behind Football Leaks. The Premier League's investigation began in December, leading to a prolonged dispute over document production and co-operation. Der Spiegel also said its evidence appeared to show former manager Roberto Mancini had a secret second contract: £1.45m net from City, plus £1.75m paid to a company connected to him for a four-day annual consultancy at Abu Dhabi club Al Jazira. That was the magazine's claim, reported again by Sky Sports in October 2026. Pinto has denied personally hacking City and says he does not consider himself a hacker; City has consistently described its emails as "hacked or stolen".
February–July 2020 / 2020
UEFA initially imposed a two-season European ban and €30m fine. CAS later overturned the ban, finding most alleged breaches not established or time-barred, but upheld a failure-to-cooperate finding and reduced the fine to €10m. This was a separate case from the Premier League proceedings.
6 February 2023 / 2023
After a four-year investigation, the League referred alleged breaches across four categories to an independent Commission. The case became known as the ‘115 charges’.
16 September–6 December 2024 / 2024
The Commission heard the case over 42 sitting days. Its published core decision refers to 37 appendices that have not been published, limiting the contract-by-contract detail available for independent scrutiny.
Chapter 04 / 2026 and beyond
What is decided, and what is not
What the Commission decided, and what remains unresolved while sanctions and appeal rights are outstanding.
29 September 2026 / 2026
The Commission found all serious financial charges proved and three of four co-operation allegations upheld. Its decision describes intentional circumvention of the rules. City denies wrongdoing and can appeal.
29 September 2026, evening / 2026
In a statement the same night, City said they were innocent, that the decision contained "clear material errors, of law, principle and fact", and that they would pursue the appeal routes open to them.
29 September 2026 / 2026
City's formal statement said the club was "both disappointed and surprised" by the decision, that it is "innocent of the accusations" and that "a comprehensive body of irrefutable evidence exists" for its positions. It promised to be "relentless, and where necessary proactive, in any and all appropriate regulatory and legal forums." The statement called it a Premier League commission; it was an independent one.
30 September 2026 / 2026
On international duty with Portugal, City defender Rúben Dias said: "I understand the question perfectly. But I also ask you to understand that I will not comment on anything that is not related to the Portugal national team."
1 October 2026 / 2026
Reuters reports that Etihad Airways is taking legal advice and that rival clubs are considering compensation claims. No sporting sanction has been imposed, and City remain top of the Premier League.
1 October 2026 / 2026
City are expected to tell an appeal board that the money topped up to sponsors came from the Abu Dhabi government, not the club’s owners, backed by what the club calls ‘irrefutable evidence’ including bank statements and witness accounts. The Commission rejected that explanation as ‘untrue’ in its findings, concluding it was concocted well after the event in an attempt to obscure and conceal the realities of the Disguised Funding Scheme.
1 October 2026 / 2026
Under new appeal rules introduced this season, the appeal must be concluded within 12 weeks and the hearing can last no longer than five days. City were charged in 2023 and heard in 2024, before those rules existed, and a legal expert told Sky Sports News the club would have a strong case for arguing they should not apply. Sky reports the club plans to file before the 2 October deadline.
1 October 2026 / 2026
Sky Sports News' Kaveh Solhekol sees two problems with arguing the roughly £830m came from the Abu Dhabi government rather than the owners. City already made that argument at the autumn 2024 hearing and the Commission dismissed it. And the line between the two is thin: City are majority owned by Sheikh Mansour's Newton Investment and Development LLC, and Sheikh Mansour is a member of Abu Dhabi's ruling family and vice president and deputy prime minister of the UAE. He called it "a long shot", but one part of City's strategy.
1 October 2026 / 2026
The Treasury Committee chair, Dame Meg Hillier MP, wrote to HMRC's permanent secretary JP Marks asking whether HMRC has an unredacted copy of the decision, seeking "reassurance from HMRC that you are seized of the importance of these issues and the public interest in the case", and an overview of its work on football clubs, including the taxation of remuneration. HMRC could examine whether City paid the right tax and national insurance across the nine seasons. A reply is due by 15 October 2026. No tax investigation has been announced.
1 October 2026 / 2026
After Prime Minister Andy Burnham said he would be concerned if City's owners left and praised their investment in Manchester, Downing Street clarified that the initial judgment was serious, nobody was above the rules and those responsible should face appropriate consequences wherever wrongdoing is established. It stressed that the independent process must be allowed to run and its outcome respected.
1 October 2026, 7pm / 2026
Manchester City confirmed that at 7pm, before the deadline, the club lodged its comprehensive appeal. The statement said: "The club's firm position is that, on multiple grounds, the opinion contains clear material errors, of law, principle and fact and is unsafe. The club is innocent of the accusations made by the Premier League and a comprehensive body of irrefutable evidence exists in support of all of its positions, relating to this case. We will continue to respect due process and are necessarily restricted in what we can say further until all proceedings are complete." The statement referred to a "Premier League Commission"; for clarity, this was an independent commission. The full grounds of appeal have not been published.
2 October 2026 / 2026
Sky Sports News' Kaveh Solhekol said City's statement calling the independent commission's judgement an opinion "just shows you what Man City think about this whole process, that even now they are refusing to call a judgement a judgement." Noting the upheld co-operation findings, he asked how the sanctioning panel or appeal board would feel about City continuing to accuse them of not being impartial by referring to their judgement as an opinion.
2 October 2026 / 2026
Sky Sports reported that Bloomberg, citing unnamed sources, said UAE officials had warned the UK government that the severity of any punishment could affect appetite for future large-scale commitments, and that the UAE regarded the case as relevant to the bilateral relationship. The Telegraph separately reported that the UAE is threatening to withdraw billions of pounds of private investment the government had been seeking for a hi-tech hub between Oxford and Cambridge. The Guardian corroborated that officials said the Premier League's actions would "have an influence on the bilateral state relationship". These are reported diplomatic concerns from unnamed sources, not an official UAE statement and not part of the Commission's findings.
2 October 2026 / 2026
On the day of City's appeal deadline, the Football Association, which governs the whole of English football, said: "The Independent Commission's decision has significant implications for the integrity of the game. We are carefully considering the decision and its implications and will take action where appropriate." It added that it would not comment further while proceedings between the Premier League and City remain ongoing, but would "continue to monitor developments closely." The FA has not said what action, if any, it might take, and has announced no charge or sanction.
2 October 2026 / 2026
Rui Pinto, the Football Leaks founder whose documents helped trigger the Premier League investigation, said Portugal was ending his witness protection on 10 October. Citing "multiple death threats" and "the serious risk of an assassination attempt", he said he would relocate to an undisclosed location. Pinto was convicted in Portugal of offences including illegal access to data and attempted extortion, receiving a four-year suspended sentence; he describes himself as a whistleblower and has denied personally hacking City.
3 October 2026 / 2026
The Guardian reports that Pinto is prepared to cooperate with UK authorities in exchange for protection, and that he holds documents relating to City's affairs that may have been overlooked during the Premier League investigation. In June 2024 he said he had handed five hard drives containing millions of documents to French and German authorities, including more material on City, some of which he believed had "criminal relevancy". His archive extends well beyond what Der Spiegel published. Whether any of the unpublished material reaches the Premier League or UK law enforcement is not yet known.
2 October 2026 / 2026
The i Paper and The Telegraph revealed that City chairman Khaldoon Al Mubarak met Business Secretary Jonathan Reynolds in Downing Street on 14 September, 15 days before the verdict was announced. A British official said Al Mubarak attended in his capacity as chief executive of the Abu Dhabi sovereign wealth fund Mubadala, that the talks covered defence, security, intelligence sharing and trade, and that Manchester City was not discussed. The meeting was not publicly announced at the time. Prime Minister Andy Burnham was not in the building following the death of his father earlier that day.
2 October 2026 / 2026
Former manager Pep Guardiola posted a public message of support: "I want every single Manchester City fan across the world to know I am here; more than ever. I am, always have been, always will, be behind my club, my owner, my chairman, Ferran, the players, staff, Enzo and you, our unique supporters. Let me be clear: we will get through this together. I love you all." Chief executive Ferran Soriano, in a video to players and staff, called the process a "Premier League conspiracy theory".
3 October 2026 / 2026
BBC Sport reports that City's expected appeal argument, that the sponsor top-ups came from the Abu Dhabi government rather than the owners, may be undermined by statements Etihad Airways gave to the US government in 2015. In response to a US Department of Transportation inquiry, Etihad described itself in terms that sit awkwardly with the claim that Abu Dhabi government money, rather than owner funding, stood behind its sponsorship. The Commission had already rejected the government-funding explanation as concocted after the event.
3 October 2026 / 2026
ESPN reports that the strength of the judgment shocked the club, its employees and its players, with most inside the City Football Academy accepting the verdict was a worst-case scenario. More than 700 employees attended an all-staff meeting in the first week of the international break. Many staff told ESPN they are choosing to believe chairman Khaldoon Al Mubarak and chief executive Ferran Soriano, or at least to wait for the appeal before passing judgment.
2 October 2026 / 2026
The Premier League confirmed that Manchester City had appealed the decision of the independent commission, adding: "The club lodged the appeal to the Chair of the Judicial Panel. The independent Appeal Board hearing will remain private and confidential until publication of the outcome is permitted." Appeal boards are appointed by the chair of the Judicial Panel, must have three members, and one of them, the chair, should have held judicial office.
2 October 2026 / 2026
Liam Byrne MP, chair of the Business and Trade Committee, wrote to the Financial Reporting Council asking how it intends to examine "the potential accounting and audit failures identified in the Manchester City judgment". His letter asks how the established system of audit and regulatory scrutiny failed to uncover misstatements on this scale over nine years, notes that the issues came to light through media reporting rather than the audit process, and asks whether any further investigation depends on the outcome of the appeal. The FRC has not announced an investigation.
2 October 2026 / 2026
Sky Sports News' Kaveh Solhekol reports that Etihad Airways is considering legal action against the Premier League and has hired what has been described as "the world's most feared law firm". The airline feels its reputation has been damaged by the implication that it was involved in wrongdoing, something it categorically denies. Separately, Solhekol says the appeal is the end of the road within the Premier League process, though City could also appeal the sanction itself, and the FA, HMRC or even the High Court could still become involved.
2 October 2026 / 2026
The Liberal Democrats called on Prime Minister Andy Burnham to disclose all meetings he has held with Manchester City's owners. The party's culture spokesperson Anna Sabine MP shared what she called a strongly-worded letter to the Prime Minister, after Burnham said he would be "really concerned" if City's owners sold the club and credited them as "a huge partner in the building of modern Manchester". Downing Street has since clarified that nobody is above the rules and the independent process must run its course.
7 October 2026 / 2026
The Independent's Miguel Delaney, drawing on legal and regulatory figures, reports one consensus of expectations: the sanction, together with the full decision and its appendices, could come next, possibly by the end of November; the appeal decision is expected between January and March 2027 and could then go to arbitration; and any appeal against the sanction could be decided by mid-May. These are expectations, not a confirmed schedule.
11 October 2026 / 2026
In their first match since the verdict, City beat Liverpool 3-0 at Anfield with goals from Erling Haaland, Jeremy Doku and Rayan Cherki, keeping a perfect six wins from six and going three points clear at the top. Home supporters sang "going down" and called City "cheats". Manager Enzo Maresca said chief executive Ferran Soriano and sporting director Hugo Viana travelled with the team: "It's togetherness that in this moment we need."
12 October 2026 / 2026
The Independent reports that Premier League club executives have exchanged messages about whether City should be suspended with immediate effect, with one senior figure calling the situation "farcical" and comparing it to "sitting in purgatory". Under Rule 6B, 15 clubs could vote on such a motion, but the report says it has no chance of happening because views conflict. No vote has been called and the Premier League has made no announcement.
12 October 2026 / 2026
Kaveh Solhekol reports that the Premier League wants the sanctions hearing held as soon as possible, while City want everything done strictly according to the rules, and notes that the appeal does not necessarily delay the sanctions hearing. Under current rules an appeal hearing should conclude within 12 weeks of being filed, with up to 30 days for a decision, which could mean an appeal verdict in January 2027. No sanctions hearing date has been announced.
Still to be decided / NEXT
City's appeal has been lodged, but its full grounds have not been published. A new three-person commission will hear it. If the new appeal rules apply, the process must conclude within 12 weeks, though City may argue those rules do not cover a case charged in 2023. No punishment was set in the core decision; a further confidential hearing will decide sanctions. City cannot appeal to the Court of Arbitration for Sport this time. A later High Court challenge would be limited to arguments about fairness and impartiality. The findings should not be treated as final while the appeal remains unresolved.
The charges / published 6 February 2023
Not a rumour mill list: the League's own announcement set out every charge, rule by rule and season by season. They fall into five kinds. The per-kind counts here are the tallies widely used since the announcement, and they add up to 115.
54
Failing to provide, in the utmost good faith, accurate financial information giving a true and fair view of the club's position: revenue, including sponsorship, related parties and operating costs.
The heart of the case. The League said money from City's owners was booked as sponsorship from independent companies, inflating revenue by hundreds of millions. The Commission agreed, finding a Disguised Funding Scheme: BBC Sport's analysis puts the owner-funded sums recorded as sponsorship at £830.69m across the nine seasons.
Commission: All proved
2009/10
B.13, C.71, C.72 and C.75 (from 10 September 2009: B.13, C.71, C.72, C.79 and C.80)
2010/11
B.13, C.78, C.79, C.86 and C.87
2011/12
B.13, C.78, C.79, C.86 and C.87
2012/13
B.16, E.3, E.4, E.11 and E.12
2013/14
B.15, E.3, E.4, E.11, E.12 and E.49
2014/15
B.16, E.3, E.4, E.11, E.12 and E.50
2015/16
B.16, E.3, E.4, E.11, E.12 and E.50
2016/17
B.16, E.3, E.4, E.11, E.12 and E.51
2017/18
B.16, E.3, E.4, E.11, E.12 and E.51
14
Failing to include full details of remuneration in the relevant contracts with managers and with players.
The 'second contract' charges. The League said some pay was routed through separate agreements kept off the official contracts, so the books understated what managers and players were really paid. Der Spiegel's 2018 leaks had claimed Roberto Mancini held such an arrangement; the decision redacts the names, so the contracts stay unnamed here too.
Commission: All proved
2009/10 to 2011/12, managers
Q.7 and Q.8
2012/13, managers
P.7 and P.8
2010/11 and 2011/12, players
K.12 and K.20
2012/13, players
T.12 and T.20
2013/14 and 2014/15, players
T.12 and T.19
2015/16, players
T.13 and T.20
5
Failing to comply with UEFA's regulations, including its Club Licensing and Financial Fair Play Regulations, the rules behind the 2020 European ban.
The European thread. UEFA banned City from the Champions League for two years in 2020 over the same broad territory, but the Court of Arbitration for Sport overturned the ban, ruling most allegations were time-barred or not established. The Premier League case faced no time bar, and these charges were proved.
Commission: All proved
2013/14
B.14.6
2014/15 to 2017/18, each season
B.15.6
7
Failing to comply with the Premier League's own Profitability and Sustainability rules, the rules Everton, Nottingham Forest and others have been punished under.
The same rulebook that docked Everton and Nottingham Forest points. Clubs may lose no more than £105m over three seasons; inflated sponsorship and hidden pay would have made City's reported losses look smaller than the true figure. The Commission found the breaches proved.
Commission: All proved
2015/16
E.52 to E.60
2016/17 and 2017/18, each season
E.53 to E.60
35
Failing to cooperate with and assist the Premier League in its investigations, including by providing documents and information in the utmost good faith.
Why the case took so long. These charges cover the investigation itself: the League said City delayed, withheld documents and failed to assist across more than four years. The Commission upheld three of the four allegations, the source of the reported '114 of 115' shorthand.
Commission: 3 of 4 upheld
2018/19
B.16, B.19, W.1, W.2, W.12 and W.13
2019/20
B.16, B.19, W.1, W.2, W.12 and W.13
2020/21
B.16, B.19, W.1, W.2, W.12 and W.13
2021/22
B.15, B.18, W.1, W.2, W.12 and W.13
2022/23
B.15, B.18, W.1, W.2, W.15 and W.16
Some analysts count higher than 115, because a single charge can bundle more than one breach, and one early estimate ran to around 130. What the announcement does not do is itemise how the counts reach 115: that arithmetic was worked out afterwards from the rule lists above. The Commission's decision, published on 29 September 2026, found all serious financial charges proved and three of four co-operation allegations upheld, the source of the reported "114 of 115" shorthand. See the decision.
All serious financial charges were found proved. Three of four co-operation allegations were upheld, the source of the reported “114 of 115” shorthand. The Commission has not yet decided a punishment, and City lodged an appeal on 1 October 2026.
Established in core decision
Financial breaches proved
The Commission's findings cover sham arrangements, misstated accounts and breaches of spending limits.
Appeal lodged
No sanction announced
City lodged their appeal at 7pm on 1 October. A separate confidential hearing will decide sanctions, and the appeal itself could run into 2027.
Primary source
Independent Commission · redacted core decision

The club at the centre of the case.
Photo: Shutterstock.
Chapter 05 / what could come next
The finding is public. The punishment is not. Section W of the 2026/27 Premier League Handbook sets out powers, not a fixed tariff for these breaches. City lodged their appeal on 1 October 2026. A new panel will hear it, while the independent Commission will decide sanctions at a separate hearing.
Section W · W.64.1–2
A reprimand or a fine with no stated upper limit.
Section W · W.64.4.1–2
Suspend a club from League matches or deduct points already scored or yet to be scored.
Section W · W.64.4.4
Recommend that the League expels a club from membership. This is not automatic relegation into the EFL.
Section W · W.64.5, 7–8
Compensation, combinations of penalties and conditional sanctions are also within the Commission’s powers.
Reported possibilities / not a ruling
Sky Sports reporters Kaveh Solhekol and Rob Dorsett list fines, points deductions and other sporting penalties as possibilities. They note the League has no preset sanctions for financial breaches: clubs chose not to have them, fearing a known price would let a club break the rules and simply pay it. In February 2025, chief executive Richard Masters said the League was looking at a sanctions grid. None is a published proposal from the Commission for City.
An agreement / possible in principle
Section W.6.7 allows a written sanction agreement between the League Board and a club. Under W.16–17, an independent panel must ratify it and may reject an unduly lenient sanction. These provisions do not establish that this already-decided Commission case will settle, or that any talks are underway. No settlement has been announced.

The competition that brought the case.
Photo: Shutterstock.
Expulsion would be a recommendation under W.64.4.4, not a Commission-ordered drop into the Championship. City could only reach the Championship through relegation after a large enough points deduction. These are available powers, not predicted outcomes.
If City were expelled, Sky Sports explains, they would have to apply to the FA to rejoin the pyramid. EFL rules place any new member in League Two; entering any higher would need a simple-majority vote of all 72 EFL clubs. The Premier League would be left with 19 clubs, almost certainly meaning only two are relegated that season, and the League would have to decide whether to void City's results if it happened mid-season.
Chapter 06 / other clubs
Real outcomes show the stakes, not a formula for City. The English cases involve financial loss limits; City's findings concern a much wider pattern of misstated income, omitted costs and co-operation failures.
Premier League · 2023/24
−8 points
A 10-point deduction for one PSR breach became six on appeal; a second, overlapping PSR case added two. Everton finished 15th, staying up.
Premier League · 2023/24
−4 points
A PSR loss-limit breach brought an immediate four-point deduction, upheld on appeal. Forest fell into the relegation zone when penalised but finished 17th and stayed up.
EFL rules · 2025/26
−6 points
A Premier League Commission recommended a six-point Championship deduction for an EFL profit-and-sustainability breach after Leicester had returned to the EFL. Its appeal failed. This was not a Premier League points deduction.
Football League · 2008/09
−30 points
Ten points for illegal payments to agents and 20 for leaving administration without a Company Voluntary Arrangement. Not a Premier League financial-rules case.
EFL · 2021/22
−21 points
Twelve points for entering administration and nine for financial irregularities. An EFL case, not a Premier League one.
Scotland · 2012 / insolvency and membership
After the old company entered liquidation, the new company was refused a Scottish Premier League place and admitted to the Scottish Football League's Third Division. Rangers spent four seasons outside the top flight, returning in 2016. This was a membership decision following insolvency, not a disciplinary relegation for financial-rule breaches.
Italy · 2006 / Calciopoli
The Italian federation demoted Juventus to Serie B after the match-officials scandal and stripped the club of two league titles. Its initial 30-point penalty was later reduced to nine. Juventus lost top-flight and European football for 2006/07, then won promotion at the first attempt. This was a sporting-integrity case under Italian rules, not a Premier League financial case.
Neither foreign example sets a precedent for the Premier League Commission. Rangers illustrates insolvency and re-admission; Juventus illustrates a sporting-integrity punishment. Neither tells us what City's sanction will be.

Beyond the Premier League.
Europe, the FA and the new regulator all have a stake in what happens next.
Chapter 06b / Beyond the League
The Premier League is not the only body with a stake. UEFA has its own history with City, the FA owns two of the cups won in the period, and England now has a football regulator. None has announced a penalty.
Europe
€30m → €10m
UEFA's 2020 fine, cut on appeal when the ban was overturned
Watching. No new action announced.
England
2 trophies
FA Cup and Community Shield won by City in the nine seasons
Quiet so far. No statement found.
Regulator
3-person panel
Where any City appeal goes, not the Court of Arbitration for Sport
Says the decision raises "serious issues".
Chapter 07 / Reactions
Former players, managers, club executives and officials have spoken since the decision. Quotes are as reported by the linked outlet. Opinions here are theirs, not findings of the Commission.
Rodri
Former City midfielder, 2019–2026
“I believe in the justice system and I believe in the innocence of the club.”Spain press conference, via the Manchester Evening News
Pep Guardiola
Former City manager, 2016–2026
“I am, always have been, always will, be behind my club, my owner, my chairman.”Social media post, via BBC Sport
Guillem Balague
Spanish football journalist
“A finding about Manchester City isn't a finding about Pep Guardiola.”BBC Radio 5 Live, via BBC Sport
Khaldoon Al Mubarak
City chairman
“Our confidence and intent in proving the club's innocence is just as strong as when this began.”Open letter to fans, via Reuters
Ferran Soriano
City chief executive
“Called the case a "Premier League conspiracy theory".”Internal video, via Sky Sports
Micah Richards
Former City defender
“I saw the words which were used by the Premier League in sham contracts and I felt absolutely devastated.”The Rest Is Football, via PA
Roy Keane
Former Man United captain
“If I was a player, I'd be 100% sticking those medals in the bin.”ITV Sport, via BBC Sport
Ian Wright
Former Arsenal striker
“Cheating on an industrial scale.”ITV Sport, via The Independent
Jamie Carragher
Former Liverpool defender
“For me, this is all about the owners.”Sky Sports, via the Mirror
Gary Neville
Former Man United defender
“To listen to this, it is chilling.”Stick to Football, via The Independent
Mauricio Pochettino
USA coach, ex-Spurs and Chelsea
“How did this happen? Where were the controls?”Press conference, via Sports Illustrated
Graham Potter
Sweden head coach, ex-Chelsea and Brighton
“It's a sad situation... not good for football, not good for the league.”Press conference, via Sky Sports News
Kaveh Solhekol
Sky Sports News chief reporter
“Even now they are refusing to call a judgement a judgement.”Sky Sports News live blog, 2 October 2026
Andrée Jeglertz
Manchester City Women head coach
“The players are very calm.”Post-match comments, via Sky Sports News
Paul Scholes
Former Man United midfielder
“I'm greedy, I want my medal.”Instagram Story, via Sky Sports News, 3 October 2026
Thomas Tuchel
England head coach
“It would be a very human reaction if you don't know what's going on for the club that you signed.”England press conference, via Sky Sports News, 2 October 2026
David Bernstein
Former City and FA chairman
“City can't stay in the Premier League.”BBC Sport live, 30 Sept 2026
Mark Palios
Former FA chief executive
“They have to be proportionate and they have to be significant.”TV interview, 30 Sept 2026
Javier Tebas
La Liga president
“It should be a punishment intended to set an example.”Fifpro summit, via The Independent
Rio Ferdinand
Former Man United defender
“Another premier league medal to be added to the cabinet.”Social media post, via ESPN
David de Gea
Former Man United goalkeeper
“So... Let's talk. How many Premier League titles have I won then?”Post on X, via ESPN
Danny Murphy
Former Liverpool midfielder
“I think it's pointless stripping them of titles that they've already won.”Interview, via the Manchester Evening News
Stefan Borson
Football finance expert, ex-City adviser
“Appeal extremely difficult.”Post on X, via TEAMtalk
David Mooney
City fan, Blue Moon podcast
“I am a bit shocked and stunned about how to process it.”BBC Radio 5 Live, via BBC Sport
Jonathan Wilson
Journalist, The Guardian
“How can Manchester City be trusted under these owners?”Column, The Guardian, 29 Sept 2026
Ian Ladyman
Football editor, Daily Mail
“For all that we can expect City to appeal this verdict, the mud attached to City's good name will stick.”Column, Daily Mail, 25 Sept 2026
John Cross
Chief football writer, the Mirror
“In my view, it would have to be relegation.”Opinion column, the Mirror, 25 Sept 2026
Rory Smith
Football correspondent, The Observer
“Without integrity, without honesty, it's not a sport at all.”Column, The Observer, 26 Sept 2026